Investment

Where a $100 Card Nets the Most After Selling Fees

On a clean $100 sale, the seller keeps about $86.35 on eBay, $86.45 on TCGplayer, $88.80 on Whatnot, and $88 to $94 in cash (or $100 in FanCash) on Fanatics Collect Buy Now. Fee schedules checked November 16, 2026.

PureGrail Editorial14 min read
Overhead view of sleeved trading cards fanned face-down on deep burgundy felt, with one card turned face-up showing abstract foil artwork, beside a blurred brass-edged bidding paddle and the corner of a catalog page in warm lamplight.

In a card selling fees comparison on a clean $100 sale (no shipping, no tax), the seller keeps about $86.35 on eBay, $86.45 on TCGplayer, $88.80 on Whatnot's base tier, and $94 or $88 in cash on Fanatics Collect Buy Now, depending on list price. Fanatics' FanCash option pays $100, but in store credit only.

We checked all four fee schedules on November 16, 2026. TCGplayer's and Whatnot's help articles were last updated November 15 and November 16, 2026. The Fanatics Collect support articles we used were updated between December 8, 2025 and October 14, 2026. eBay's help pages show no effective or last-updated date, so treat eBay's figures as published on November 16, 2026.

The gap between the cheapest and most expensive cash option on a $100 card is about $8. That's smaller than a lot of sellers assume, and the details below matter more than the headline rates do: how each platform defines the fee base, whether you want cash or credit, and whether the card is graded and already in a vault.

How we ran the numbers

One $100 card, two scenarios:

  • Scenario A: $100 item price, no shipping charged to the buyer, no sales tax.

  • Scenario B: $100 item, $5 shipping and $8 sales tax, for a $113 order total.

The fee base explains most of the gap between the scenarios. eBay charges its percentage on the whole order, including shipping and sales tax. TCGplayer and Whatnot charge their processing fees on the full order total. Whatnot's commission excludes shipping and tax. All Scenario B figures are before you pay for the shipping label.

eBay: 13.25% plus $0.40, no separate processing fee

Under eBay's selling-fees page, non-Store and Starter Store sellers in Collectible Card Games, Non-Sport Trading Cards and Sports Trading Cards pay 13.25% "on total amount of the sale up to $7,500 calculated per item," then 2.35% on the portion above $7,500. The per-order fee is $0.30 on orders of $10.00 or less and $0.40 on orders over $10.00. eBay says sellers "don't have to worry about third-party payment processing fees," so there's no second processing charge.

eBay's "total amount of the sale" includes the item price, handling, shipping charged to the buyer and sales tax. The page notes that "some exceptions apply" to shipping, such as eBay International Shipping.

  • Scenario A: $13.25 + $0.40 = $13.65 in fees. Net: $86.35.

  • Scenario B: 13.25% of $113 is about $14.97, plus $0.40, for about $15.37 in fees. You keep about $89.63 of the $105 in item plus shipping.

Store subscribers on Basic, Premium, Anchor and Enterprise plans pay 12.35% in the same card categories on sales up to $2,500 per item, and 2.35% above that. On a $100 card that's $12.35 + $0.40 = $12.75, for a net of $87.25.

A few other eBay costs can show up:

  • A 1.65% international fee for US sellers who don't use eBay International Shipping when the buyer or item is outside the US.

  • Below Standard sellers pay an extra 6% on final value fees the following month, rising to 7% after four or more consecutive months.

  • Standard payouts list no fee. Express payouts cost a flat $2.00 each.

TCGplayer: 10.75% commission plus 2.5% and $0.30

TCGplayer's fee table (updated November 15, 2026) charges Marketplace Sellers at Level 1 to 4 a 10.75% commission plus a "2.5% + $.30" transaction fee. Commission is charged on the order subtotal and capped at $75 per product sold. The transaction fee is charged on the "order total [items + shipping + tax]." International orders carry a 3.5% + $0.30 transaction fee.

That 10.75% is new this year. TCGplayer's January 8, 2026 seller blog post raised the Level 1 to 4 commission from 10.25% and the cap from $50 to $75, effective February 10, 2026.

  • Scenario A: $10.75 commission + $2.80 transaction fee = $13.55. Net: $86.45.

  • Scenario B: the transaction fee rises to about $3.13 (2.5% of $113, plus $0.30).

Other seller types pay different rates:

TCGplayer seller typeCommissionOther fees
Marketplace Seller (Level 1-4)10.75%2.5% + $0.30 transaction fee
Pro (non-Direct)9.25%2.5% Pro fee, plus 2.5% + $0.30
Sync (Crystal Commerce, BinderPOS, Ion)9.25%2.5% + $0.30
Direct8.95%2.5% transaction fee

Direct also changed on June 18, 2026. According to TCGplayer's May 13 seller blog post, cards selling for $2.49 or less now carry a 50% fee, cards above $2.49 carry a flat $1.12 fee, and the $0.30 transaction fee is gone from Direct orders, though the 2.5% fee continues. The help article confirms that commission, Pro, Sync and transaction fees are left off Direct cards at $2.49 or below. That matters a lot for bulk sellers and very little for a $100 single.

Whatnot: 8% on the item, 2.9% plus $0.30 on everything

Whatnot's seller-fees article (updated November 16, 2026) sets the US base commission for Sports/TCG at 8.00% for sellers with $0 to $14,999 in sales over a four-week period. Commission is charged on the item's sale price, and "shipping and taxes paid by the buyer are not included." US payment processing is 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction, charged on the buyer's full order value, shipping and tax included.

  • Scenario A: $8.00 commission + $3.20 processing = $11.20. Net: $88.80.

  • Scenario B: $8.00 commission + about $3.58 processing = about $11.58. You keep about $93.42 of the $105 in item plus shipping.

Scenario B is where Whatnot pulls ahead of eBay. The $5 shipping and $8 tax add about $0.38 to Whatnot's fees, compared with about $1.72 on eBay, because Whatnot keeps them out of the commission base.

Whatnot's tiered Sports/TCG structure "took effect September 21, 2026 for existing sellers," as Net Influencer also reported:

Sales over four weeksSports/TCG commission
$0 to $14,9998.00%
$15,000 to $34,9997.75%
$35,000 to $49,9997.50%
$50,000 to $99,9997.25%
$100,000 to $249,9997.00%
$250,000 to $499,9996.75%
$500,000+6.50%

Whatnot says "rates as low as 3%" are custom rates for top-volume sellers. As of November 1, 2026, Premier Shop no longer includes a 10% commission discount in markets with tiered rates.

For expensive cards, Whatnot has charged 0% base commission on the portion of a sale above $1,500 since January 14, 2026. It applies only to the Trading Card Games and Sports Cards Singles subcategories (sports breaks and Surprise Products are excluded), and processing is still charged on the full amount. It doesn't change anything on a $100 card.

Fanatics Collect: three different answers

Buy Now: 6% or 12%, depending on your price

Under Fanatics Collect's Buy Now rules (updated December 8, 2025), listings priced under 120% of Card Ladder market value pay a 6% seller fee, and listings at or above 120% pay 12%. The fee is based on the final sale price. If you accept an offer within the "Great Price" threshold, you get the 6% rate. There's no minimum fee, and buyers pay no Buy Now purchase fees, though a fulfillment fee applies if the buyer ships the card out of the vault.

Three graded card slabs standing in a row on a dark wooden table in warm lamplight, each showing abstract foil artwork, with a blurred bidding paddle and catalog edge behind them.

On a $100 sale, that's $94 at 6% or $88 at 12%. ACH payouts have "No processing fee" (US only). Wire transfers and rush next-business-day payouts cost $50 each, which would wipe out most of a $100 sale. Regular payouts go out on Wednesdays, with a Tuesday-midnight ET cutoff.

The 120% line is the number to watch. A card priced well above recent value pays twice the fee, and at 12% Fanatics nets less than Whatnot's base tier and only about $1.65 more than eBay.

Weekly Auction: no seller fee, but the buyer pays 20%

"There are no fees to sell graded collectibles in Weekly or Premier Auctions," according to Fanatics Collect's selling page. Sellers get 100% of the winning bid plus an eligible bonus commission. But a separate support article says a "20% buyer's premium is added to the hammer price of all sales."

So compare on what the buyer pays. A $100 hammer costs the buyer $120. A buyer with $100 to spend all-in can bid about $83.33, and that's roughly what you'd receive before any bonus commission. That's below every cash option above. Buyers bid with the premium in mind.

Two vault rules from the same page: collectibles valued under $50 that go into the vault and aren't sent to auction incur a one-time $3 fee, and unsold auction items return to the vault, where sellers must wait 90 days before relisting.

FanCash: 100%, paid in credit

Fanatics Collect launched FanCash payouts on July 31, 2026. Sports Illustrated reported that US sellers who choose FanCash keep 100% of sale proceeds on Buy Now and Auction sales, with no earning limit, and that standard vault fees are unchanged. Fanatics CEO Nick Bell told SI: "Giving people the ability to keep 100% of their proceeds, we think, is just so collector-focused."

There are limits. Heavy reports that sellers have to select FanCash before listing, and that FanCash proceeds can't be moved to a bank account and must be spent within Fanatics businesses. Mantel, via Yahoo Sports, reports that standard vault storage and fulfillment fees still apply.

Because $100 in FanCash isn't $100 in cash, the real comparison is between the $6 you'd pay at the 6% Buy Now rate and how sure you are that you'll spend that credit at Fanatics anyway.

Fee table: $100 card, Scenario A

Platform and tierFee rateFee basisFixed feeNet on $100Source date
eBay (non-Store, Starter Store)13.25% up to $7,500Item + shipping + tax$0.40 per order over $10$86.35As published Nov. 16, 2026
eBay (Basic Store and up)12.35% up to $2,500Item + shipping + tax$0.40 per order over $10$87.25As published Nov. 16, 2026
TCGplayer (Level 1-4)10.75% + 2.5%Commission on subtotal (capped at $75); 2.5% on items + shipping + tax$0.30$86.45Nov. 15, 2026
Whatnot (Sports/TCG base)8% + 2.9%Commission on item price; 2.9% on buyer's full total$0.30$88.80Nov. 16, 2026
Fanatics Collect Buy Now (under 120% of Card Ladder)6%Final sale priceNone$94 cashDec. 8, 2025
Fanatics Collect Buy Now (120% or more)12%Final sale priceNone$88 cashDec. 8, 2025
Fanatics Collect with FanCash0%n/aNone (vault fees still apply)$100 in FanCashJuly 31, 2026 reporting
Fanatics Collect Weekly Auction (graded)0% seller; 20% buyer's premiumHammer priceNone$100 hammer (buyer pays $120)Sept. 28 and Oct. 14, 2026

What changes the ranking

Overhead view of a trading card in a rigid top-loader beside an open padded mailer, tape roll, scissors and a blurred brass postal scale on dark navy felt, lit by warm lamplight.

  • Your Fanatics list price. Crossing 120% of Card Ladder value moves Buy Now from the cheapest cash option to the middle of the pack.

  • Your eBay Store tier. Basic and up cuts the rate to 12.35% on sales up to $2,500, which puts eBay a bit ahead of TCGplayer Level 1 to 4 on a $100 card.

  • Your Whatnot volume. Tiers start at $15,000 in sales over four weeks, so most hobby sellers will pay the 8% base rate.

  • Shipping and tax. The more of the order that's shipping and tax, the more eBay's all-in fee base costs you compared with Whatnot's.

  • Cash or credit. FanCash is the only 100% option, and Heavy reports it can't go to a bank.

  • International buyers. eBay adds 1.65% if you don't use eBay International Shipping. TCGplayer's transaction fee goes to 3.5% + $0.30.

What to do this week

  • Selling a raw TCG single for cash: the fee difference between eBay and TCGplayer Level 1 to 4 is a dime on a $100 card. Choose the platform where your recent sold comps are strongest. A better sale price will outweigh that fee difference. If you already sell on Whatnot, its base tier keeps about $2.35 more on a clean $100 sale.

  • Selling a graded card already in the Fanatics vault: price Buy Now under 120% of Card Ladder value to get the 6% rate and $94 by free ACH. Before choosing the Weekly Auction, work out what you'd net if buyers bid with the 20% premium built in.

  • Selling to fund your next Fanatics purchase: FanCash saves you $6 at the 6% rate and $12 at 12%. You have to choose it before listing, and it only makes sense if you were going to spend that money there anyway.

  • Charging buyers shipping on eBay: remember the 13.25% applies to that shipping and to the sales tax too. Price your label costs with that in mind.

  • Deciding whether to grade before selling: plug your own grading fee, shipping and expected sale prices into the card grading break-even tool. It compares the extra net proceeds from grading using the costs you enter. It doesn't predict grades, current prices or returns. Our sold-comps guide covers how to set the sale price you enter.

Sources

Note: This article contains AI-assisted content and has been reviewed in our editorial workflow.

DISCLAIMER: PureGrail articles are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Nothing on this site constitutes financial, investment, or legal advice. Collectibles are speculative assets and values can decrease significantly. Always conduct your own research before buying or selling. Past price performance does not indicate future results.

Share this
Share

Frequently asked questions

Which platform charges the lowest fees on a $100 card?

For a cash payout, Fanatics Collect Buy Now is lowest at 6% ($94 net) when the card is listed under 120% of Card Ladder market value. Next is Whatnot's base tier at $88.80, then eBay and TCGplayer at about $86.35 and $86.45. These figures assume no shipping or tax.

Does eBay charge its final value fee on shipping and sales tax?

Yes. eBay's 'total amount of the sale' includes the item price, handling, shipping charged to the buyer and sales tax, with some exceptions such as eBay International Shipping. eBay doesn't charge a separate payment processing fee.

What is TCGplayer's seller commission in 2026?

Level 1 to 4 Marketplace Sellers pay 10.75% commission, up from 10.25% on February 10, 2026, capped at $75 per product. They also pay a 2.5% + $0.30 transaction fee on items, shipping and tax.

Does Whatnot charge commission on shipping?

No. Whatnot's commission is charged on the item's sale price and excludes buyer-paid shipping and tax. Its 2.9% + $0.30 US processing fee does apply to the buyer's full order total.

Can FanCash from Fanatics Collect be withdrawn to a bank?

Heavy reports that FanCash proceeds can't be moved to a bank account and must be spent within Fanatics businesses. Sellers have to choose FanCash before listing, and standard vault fees still apply.

The Newsletter

Keep pulling smart.

Weekly market moves, grading tips, auction highlights.

Keep reading

More in Investment

DISCLAIMER: PureGrail articles are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Nothing on this site constitutes financial, investment, or legal advice. Collectibles are speculative assets and values can decrease significantly. Always conduct your own research before buying or selling. Past price performance does not indicate future results.