The buyer's premium card auction houses charge is a fee added on top of the winning bid (the hammer price). Goldin and Heritage currently charge 22% with per-lot minimums of $19 and $29. Fanatics Collect and Alt charge 20%. eBay charges buyers no premium. Most published auction results include the premium, so a $1,000 hammer usually shows up as $1,200 or $1,220.
That last point causes more bad comps than anything else in this guide. One card can carry three different "prices": what the buyer paid all-in, the hammer or item price, and what the seller actually netted. If you put a premium-inclusive auction result next to a raw eBay sold price, you aren't comparing like with like.
The terms on an auction invoice
Hammer price is the winning bid. Buyer's premium is the percentage the house adds to it, sometimes with a flat minimum per lot. Price realized is hammer plus premium. GoCollect's January 2026 explainer uses the standard example: a $1,000 hammer plus a 20% premium makes a $1,200 price realized, before tax and shipping.
The buyer also pays shipping and sales tax, and possibly a surcharge for paying by card. On the seller's side, the consignor commission or seller fee is what the venue deducts from the hammer, though some houses pay sellers the full hammer or more and fund that out of the premium.
Current buyer's premium rates by venue
| Venue | Buyer's premium | Per-lot minimum | Source and date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Goldin (Marketplace, Weekly, Elite) | 22% | $19 | Goldin's site |
| Heritage (sports) | 22% | $29 | May 15-17, 2026 Spring Sports Catalog Auction listing, per Auction Report |
| Fanatics Collect auctions | 20% | Not stated | Help-center wording quoted by Online Queso, Aug 2026 |
| Fanatics Collect Buy Now | None | n/a | Online Queso, Aug 2026 |
| Alt auctions | 20% | Not stated | Alt help center, updated May 22, 2025 |
| eBay | None (the seller pays a final value fee) | n/a | eBay selling fees page |
These rates change. Cardlines reported in 2021 that Heritage's sports premium was 20% with a $14 minimum. Card Capsule says Goldin raised its premium from 20% to 22% in 2024. So a Heritage or Goldin comp from a few years back may include a smaller premium than a sale today, even if the hammer was the same.
Goldin's weekly auctions open Tuesday at 8 AM ET and close every Thursday at 10 PM ET. Elite auctions run 17 days on dates that vary. All three formats carry the same 22% and $19 minimum.
The minimum premium hits cheap cards hardest
The percentage only applies once it's bigger than the flat minimum. At Goldin, 22% equals $19 at a hammer of about $86.36. At Heritage, 22% equals $29 at about $131.82. On any hammer below those levels you pay the flat minimum, and as a share of the card's price it can be large:

-
$50 hammer at Goldin: $69 before shipping and tax, an effective premium of 38%.
-
$50 hammer at Heritage: $79, an effective premium of 58%.
-
$20 hammer at Goldin: $39, an effective premium of 95%.
Higher up, the minimum drops out of the picture. A $1,000 hammer costs $1,220 at Goldin or Heritage and $1,200 at Fanatics Collect or Alt, before shipping and tax.
For budget collectors this changes where it makes sense to buy. A $20 or $50 card at a major house can easily cost more all-in than the same card on eBay, where the buyer pays no premium. This is the same math behind our guide on whether slabbing a $30 card is ever worth it: fixed per-item costs eat low-value cards alive.
A real invoice, line by line
Online Queso published a real Fanatics Collect invoice from August 2026:

-
Winning bid: $1,475.00
-
Buyer's premium (20%): $295.00
-
Shipping: $25.00
-
Sales tax: $107.70
-
Invoice total: $1,902.70
Paying with Visa added a 2.9% card fee in that buyer's case. For comparison, the same writer bought a Bo Jackson card on eBay for $1,625.00 plus $20.00 shipping with $0 tax, so $1,645.00 total. The eBay listing price was higher than the Fanatics bid, but the total was lower.
The bid is not your cost, and the gap between them was about $428 on that invoice before the card fee. Set your budget on the all-in number.
Where the premium goes on the seller side
For sellers it works the other way. The buyer's premium partly pays for consignor terms that look generous on paper.
-
Alt charges sellers no fees on auction proceeds. Instead it pays a bonus over hammer, from 104% (Base tier, lots under $1,000) up to 115% (all tiers, $200,000 and up), according to its help center.
-
Fanatics Collect sellers got 100% of the hammer plus a bonus commission on auction sales over $50, and up to 94% (a 6% fee) on Buy Now sales under $120, according to Auction Report in September 2024. Those are 2024 terms.
-
Goldin lists an 8.3% seller fee on Marketplace (fixed-price) sales from $0 to $249,999 on its site, down from earlier tiers of 16.7%, 12.5% and 10% on lower price bands. It doesn't publish an auction consignor commission. That field says "Contact Sales." One consignor told The Hobby Wire in August 2026 that Goldin took "5% of the sale price plus the entirety of the buyer's premium." That was one seller's contract, not a published rate.
-
eBay charges sellers of trading cards (sports, non-sport and collectible card games) a final value fee of 13.25% of the total sale up to $7,500 per item and 2.35% on the portion above $7,500, plus $0.30 per order at $10.00 or less and $0.40 above. The fee base includes shipping charged to the buyer and sales tax, with some exceptions (eBay).
A worked eBay example, assuming free shipping and a hypothetical 8% tax: a $1,000 sale creates a $1,080 fee base. The fee is $143.10 (13.25%) plus $0.40, so the seller nets $856.50 before paying for shipping and supplies. If an auction house shows that same card at $1,220, the gap between what the buyer paid and what an eBay seller keeps is more than $360.
How to adjust auction results before using them as comps
-
Find out which number you're looking at. Headline results are usually premium-inclusive. ICv2 reported that a PSA 10 Alpha Black Lotus sold at the 2026 Summer Goldin 100 "for $2.208 million (including buyer's premium)." GoCollect says it shows "the final realized price reported by the source" and doesn't normalize premiums. If a comp tool doesn't say which basis it uses, don't assume it's hammer.
-
Pick one basis and convert everything to it. Use buyer all-in cost if you're deciding what to bid, and seller net if you're deciding where to sell. Hammer or item price works as a neutral middle ground.
-
Back out the premium carefully. At a flat 22%, hammer = price realized ÷ 1.22. At 20%, divide by 1.20. A $1,220 Goldin result comes back to a $1,000 hammer. This only works above the minimum-premium threshold and only if the lot wasn't charged a tiered rate. Below about $86 at Goldin or $132 at Heritage, subtract the flat minimum instead.
-
Add shipping and tax if you want buyer cost. An eBay sold price usually doesn't include them.
-
Subtract venue fees if you want seller net: eBay's final value fee and per-order fee, or whatever commission your consignment contract specifies.
-
Weight by date. Heritage went from 20% with a $14 minimum to 22% with a $29 minimum, and Goldin from 20% to 22%. An older result with the same price realized can mean a slightly higher hammer than a recent one.
Our sold-comps guide covers the rest of the method: filtering best offers, lots and outliers.
When the premium-inclusive price is the right number
GoCollect reports that Heritage's appraisal department holds that fair market value "should always include the buyer's premium." That view makes sense if the question is what a buyer had to pay to get the card. Price realized is the actual cost of acquisition.
It's the wrong number if you own the card and want to know what you'd walk away with by listing it on eBay. A $1,220 auction result doesn't mean your copy will sell for $1,220 there, and even if it did, you'd keep about 87 cents of each dollar after eBay's fee. Use the premium-inclusive price for buy decisions and the seller-net figure for sell decisions.
Setting a max bid, consigning, or grading to sell
Bidding. Start from the most you'll pay all-in. Subtract expected shipping and tax, then divide by 1.22 (or 1.20 at a 20% house). With a $500 ceiling and about $60 of shipping and tax, ($500 - $60) ÷ 1.22 gives a max bid of roughly $360. At that hammer the premium is $79.20, which puts you at $499.20 all-in. On cheap lots under the minimum threshold, subtract the flat minimum instead of dividing. Check whether paying by card adds a surcharge, as it did on the Fanatics invoice above.
Consigning. Compare your estimated net under the consignment terms (commission, plus whatever premium share or bonus applies) against your estimated eBay net. Get the auction house's commission in writing, because Goldin, for one, doesn't publish it.
Grading then selling. Grading adds another layer of fees before any of the selling costs above. Our card grading break-even tool compares incremental net proceeds from grading using costs you enter yourself. It doesn't predict grades, current prices or returns, so the sold comps you put into it need to be on the correct basis.
Premiums, minimums and payment surcharges vary by event and have gone up in recent years. Read the terms page for the specific auction before you place a bid.
Related reading
-
Did 1962 Topps Mike Ditka Rookie Value Hold After His Death?
-
Inside the Rookie Class on the 2026-27 Topps Flagship Basketball Checklist
-
Should You Sell the Mihawk Alt Art After the OP14-020 Leader Ban?
Sources
-
Cardlines, Heritage Auctions Review: The Auction Action Series
-
Online Queso, Fanatics Collect vs eBay: What a Card Really Costs You
-
Card Capsule, Best Online Marketplaces for Sports Card Collectors
-
GoCollect, What Every Collector Needs to Know About Buyer's Premium
-
ICv2, Magic: The Gathering PSA 10 Alpha Black Lotus Sells Over $2.2 Million
DISCLAIMER: PureGrail articles are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Nothing on this site constitutes financial, investment, or legal advice. Collectibles are speculative assets and values can decrease significantly. Always conduct your own research before buying or selling. Past price performance does not indicate future results.
Note: This article contains AI-assisted content and has been reviewed in our editorial workflow.


