To spot a fake PSA slab when the cert number checks out, type the cert into PSA's site yourself, then match the record's details, and its images where they exist, to the card in hand. Inspect the label and holder for tampering, and buy through eBay's Authenticity Guarantee when the card qualifies. A clean lookup proves only that the number exists.
-
Type the cert number into PSA's site yourself. Don't use the seller's link or screenshot.
-
Match the name, set, year, card number, variant and grade exactly.
-
Compare the physical card to the record's images where they exist.
-
Check the label against a known-genuine label from the same era.
-
Look over the holder for signs it was opened or re-cased.
-
Buy through a platform check like eBay's Authenticity Guarantee when the card qualifies.
These steps matter more this month than usual. Dexerto reported on November 10 that an AliExpress listing, shown in a video by collectibles commentator Max Long, appeared to cost $4.05 and showed more than 5,000 sales. The listing was sold as a customizable label, not as a PSA-graded item. Two days earlier, the verification company CheckCOA published an investigation that tied six real PSA cert numbers to AliExpress label kits.
These kits are a problem because they use real numbers. A buyer who looks one up gets a valid PSA record. The record belongs to some other card, though, and it may not even be the same grade.
What's being sold
CheckCOA found an AliExpress store called "BEST REPLICA LABELS YOU'LL FIND" selling a "DIY custom rating card label." As of November 8 it showed 170 sold and a 4.7-star rating. Buyer photos on that listing showed labels printed with real PSA cert numbers for a 2024 Paldean Fates Mew ex SIR graded MINT 9 and a 2000 Rocket Dark Gyarados Holo Prerelease graded GEM MT 10. A second store, "High Quality Cards Store," had 146 sold as of the same date and makes custom labels from details the buyer supplies. According to Dexerto, that store's video showed a copied label with a silver patch that caught the light like a genuine one.
Dexerto also reported that Japanese collector Pokemonlana posted screenshots on November 8 of similar labels carrying two different PSA cert numbers, one of them on a Dark Persian front label, and that buyers had left positive reviews. Game Rant reported that several AliExpress sellers offer these labels for Pokémon TCG, One Piece and other games.
According to CheckCOA, PSA has deactivated two of the cert numbers it traced to the kits: a 2002 Dark Persian Reverse Foil NM-MT 8 and a 2025 Gundam Wing Gundam Zero GEM MT 10. When CheckCOA ran its own lookup for its post, a third number, for a 2023 One Piece OP06 Roronoa Zoro Manga Alternate Art GEM MT 10, still returned an active record. So the fact that a number hasn't been deactivated tells you nothing about whether it has been copied.
There's a second route. CheckCOA documented a bundle on a Japanese flea-market app, sold for 6,800 yen, made up of PSA, BGS and ARS labels that had been removed from their cases: three PSA, two BGS and three ARS. CheckCOA lists these loose labels as suspected counterfeits, not confirmed ones. If they are real, the risk is different. A genuine label could be put in a holder with a different card inside.
Step 1: Read the record, not only the number
Type the cert number into PSA's site yourself. A seller's link or screenshot is the very thing you are trying to check, so it can't be the evidence. Compare the card name, set, year, card number, variant and grade on the record to what's in the holder. Any mismatch ends the deal. "Charizard" on a record isn't a match if the year, variant or card number is different.

Then compare the card itself to the record's images where they exist. Look at centering, print lines, edge wear and corner details, since those differ from one copy of a card to the next. Game Rant's advice is that "Collectors are encouraged to carefully scrutinize the card and the connected PSA webpage to ensure that the pictures match up to the actual card." CheckCOA puts it more briefly: "Compare the card with the grader's record, not just the text."
Dexerto reports that PSA's own guidance warns that checking a certification number doesn't eliminate counterfeit risk, because fraudsters can copy real numbers from public records. Per Dexerto, PSA advises comparing cards with PSA's images, inspecting cases for tampering and buying from trusted sellers. Dexerto did not include a direct PSA response to the AliExpress listings.
Step 2: Ask whether the grade fits the card
A fake label can put a GEM MT 10 on a card that would never get one. Look at the card as if it were raw. If you can see whitening, an off-center print or a corner ding, then a 10 on the label should make you more suspicious, not less. Most of CheckCOA's examples were MINT 9 and GEM MT 10 labels on modern TCG chase cards. That's where a swapped card earns the most, so that's where you should be strictest.
Step 3: Inspect the label
Compare the font, spacing and alignment to a slab you know is genuine from the same label era. In 2017, Sports Collectors Digest reported on PSA's label redesign. The new label had a Lighthouse hologram that switches on and off as you tilt it. It had a PSA logo on the lower left of the reverse that "will illuminate to reveal additional smaller PSA logos, when hit with a UV light." It used fugitive ink designed to wash away with cleaning chemicals, and it had a QR code on the back that opens the item's record. Slabs graded before that redesign won't have these features, so compare older labels with others from their own period.
Don't lean on any one of these features. Dexerto's report on the silver patch means a shiny hologram doesn't prove much. And a QR code that opens a valid record is just the cert lookup again. If the number was copied, the code can send you to a real record for a different card.
Step 4: Inspect the holder
The kits CheckCOA and Dexerto describe come with unsealed cases. A card can go into one of these, or a genuine label can be moved into a new holder. Ask for clear photos of both sides of the slab. A seller with a real slab has no reason to refuse. Check the photos for anything that suggests the case was opened, resealed or swapped. CheckCOA's advice: "Treat a recently re-cased high-grade slab as unverified until the card matches the record."

Step 5: Use eBay's Authenticity Guarantee where it applies
On eBay, the Authenticity Guarantee for trading cards sends eligible cards to an authenticator before they reach you. For graded cards, PSA authenticates the case and label. eBay states that "No regrading is performed." If the holder is counterfeit or has been tampered with, PSA deactivates the cert. If the authenticator can't verify the item, or it doesn't match the listing, the card isn't shipped to you and you get a full refund. eBay says inspection is generally processed within 2 business days of the item arriving at the authenticator. eBay's buyer FAQ says PSA "may" re-holder an authentic, uncompromised card with a new cert. The seller-facing terms say "will."
The program has limits. From eBay's help page:
-
"Cards must have a Buy It Now price of $200 or more, or sell in an auction for $200 or more." A card listed at $200 or more Buy It Now still qualifies if it sells for less. Tax and shipping don't count toward the threshold.
-
Only PSA, Beckett (BGS), SGC and CGC Cards slabs are accepted. eBay lists GMA, HGA, KSA, WCG and GBA as examples of graders it doesn't accept.
-
Buyers must be in the continental US. Sellers must be in the continental US or Canada, and Canadian sellers can only list raw cards, so a graded card from a Canadian seller isn't covered.
-
Listings with local pickup, in-store pickup or PO box delivery aren't eligible.
-
Items that sell for $750 or more need signature confirmation when shipped to the authenticator. The inspection doesn't verify in-person autographs or aftermarket patches and relics.
A $4 label is most profitable on a card worth well into three or four figures, and those sales usually clear the $200 bar. A slab sold for less, from a grader eBay doesn't accept, or to a buyer outside the continental US gets none of this protection. In those cases, steps 1 through 4 are all you have.
Red flags that should end a deal
-
The seller won't send sharp photos of both sides of the slab.
-
The photos don't match PSA's images, or the record's details differ from the card in any way.
-
The seller pushes for local pickup or wants to finish the sale off eBay, which takes it out of eBay's program.
-
A high-grade slab has recently been re-cased.
-
The price is too good to be true, which Game Rant also warns about.
As CheckCOA puts it: "A clean result is not a guarantee, but a warning is a reason to stop."
Context: counterfeits were already rising
Fake labels add to an existing counterfeit-card problem. Sports Collectors Digest reported that PSA's 2025 Fraud Report put the projected market value of fraudulent collectibles PSA intercepted at $200 million. The report showed counterfeit collectibles overall up 45.3% year over year, counterfeit Pokémon cards up 125% and counterfeit sports cards up 5.1%. ICv2 also reported the Pokémon increase as over 125% and the interceptions as over $200 million.
Each check on its own can be beaten. A copied number passes the lookup, a silver patch passes a quick look at the hologram, and a raw counterfeit in an unsealed case can look fine in a blurry photo. A fake has a much harder time passing an exact record match, an image comparison, a label and holder inspection and a third-party authenticator all at once. If a seller won't let you run one of those checks, don't buy.
Related reading
-
Delta Reign pull rates can't yet tell you which Mega Rayquaza is the chase
-
Why Sellers Disagree on How Many PSA 10 Art Academy Mudkips Exist
Sources
-
CheckCOA: Fake PSA Label Kits on AliExpress and Loose Graded Labels (Nov 8, 2026)
-
Sports Collectors Digest: PSA labels get new look, new technology (June 26, 2017)
-
ICv2: Pokemon TCG card counterfeiting surged in 2025 (May 8, 2026)
DISCLAIMER: PureGrail articles are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Nothing on this site constitutes financial, investment, or legal advice. Collectibles are speculative assets and values can decrease significantly. Always conduct your own research before buying or selling. Past price performance does not indicate future results.
This article contains AI-assisted content and has been reviewed in our editorial workflow.


